Former Prosecutor TJ Harker Argues Derek Chauvin Did Not Kill George Floyd

Former federal prosecutor TJ Harker told Blaze News in an interview published Sunday that Derek Chauvin did not kill George Floyd, and he makes the full argument in “American Scapegoat,” a Passage Press book due Dec. 1. I read it and want to go through his main points as his argument, because several rest on trial testimony and prosecutors’ memos that can be checked.

The delay and the force

Harker said Chauvin and Officer Tou Thao called a Code 3 for an ambulance about three minutes after Floyd went to the ground. Emergency medical services were about half a mile away, he said, yet “they weren’t dispatched for nine minutes after Thao made the Code 3 call.”

Harker said the officers used “No punches, no kicks,” and no pepper spray, Taser or baton.

The medical examiner and the changing theory

Dr. Andrew Baker, the Hennepin County medical examiner, performed the autopsy. Harker said that within 24 hours of Floyd’s death Baker was telling prosecutors there was no evidence of asphyxiation, and that this appears in prosecutors’ memos to file.

According to Harker, prosecutors first went with a “blood choke,” compressing the carotid artery, and eyewitness Donald Williams testified to that on the first day of testimony. He said that by closing arguments the state had shifted to positional asphyxia, the theory he said prosecutors ruled out on May 26, 2020.

The pills and the audio

Harker said that in January 2021, weeks before trial, Chauvin’s attorney Eric Nelson asked to search the squad car and found partially dissolved pills containing methamphetamine and fentanyl with Floyd’s saliva and DNA.

He also described a dispute over what Floyd said on the ground. Harker said Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension agent James Reyerson testified on cross-examination that Floyd said “I ate too many drugs,” and that after a 10-minute break Reyerson returned and testified it was “I ain’t do no drugs.” Harker said that “strongly indicates that prosecutors coached him to change his testimony.”

What a pardon could do

Harker said a presidential pardon would reach only Chauvin’s federal charges. “The president can’t pardon state charges,” he said. “The governor can, and Governor Walz is not going to pardon Derek Chauvin.” Chauvin’s attorney, Greg Joseph, has filed for post-conviction relief, he said.

The record

A Hennepin County jury convicted Chauvin on April 20, 2021, of second-degree murder, third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter, and he was sentenced to more than 22 years. He pleaded guilty to federal civil rights charges in 2021, and another inmate stabbed him at FCI Tucson in 2023. The Hennepin County Medical Examiner’s Office told Blaze that it “stands behind the findings of the original death investigation,” including the manner and cause of death on the death certificate.

The bottom line

I am not going to tell you Chauvin is innocent. A jury convicted him, the medical examiner’s office stands by its work, and Harker’s account is one side of the case.

His points are specific, though, and they concern the record. If nine minutes passed before medical help was dispatched, if the medical examiner told prosecutors within a day that he saw no evidence of asphyxiation, if the state’s theory changed during the trial, and if a witness changed his account of Floyd’s words after a break, a court can check each of those against the transcripts. Greg Joseph’s post-conviction petition is where that should happen.

I think the case deserves a hard second look in that court,. A conviction that is sound will survive the scrutiny.